• Forest for the Trees
  • THE FOREST FOR THE TREES is about writing, publishing and what makes writers tick. This blog is dedicated to the self loathing that afflicts most writers. A community of like-minded malcontents gather here. I post less frequently now, but hopefully with as much vitriol. Please join in! Gluttons for punishment can scroll through the archives.

    If I’ve learned one thing about writers, it’s this: we really are all alone. Thanks for reading. Love, Betsy

Guest Blogger #3 – Linda Carbone

How are you supposed to behave when a good friend becomes a famous writer? When she invites you to a reading and you feel the urge to rush out the moment she heads back to her seat, but you can’t figure out how to exit? What are you supposed to do, wave at her across the room as you lope outside for air?

I don’t love her stories or novels, mind you, but to be fair I can only read them with one eye open. We’d known each other since college and sent long letters at Christmas for 25 years after that, full of funny, self-deprecating descriptions of our lives. And we always remembered each others’  birthdays. Then she stopped responding to my cards, so I stopped sending them. Was it her rejection or her success that turned my feelings of friendship to schadenfreude?

I seethed in jealousy. I swam in it. I lost hours on the Internet reading fawning praise of her talent, brightening at the occasional blunt criticism.

What, I wonder, has it been like to have the huge advances and the fat royalty checks, the prize money and the invitations to speak at packed auditoriums? Surely her intention wasn’t to torture me and make me feel invisible, but she has managed to do that nonetheless.

She and I shared an apartment in New York for a year after college. For her birthday that year, her parents gave her two tickets to the ballet, and she invited me. We watched an exhilarating performance: the magic of Baryshnikov from fourth-row seats. Leaving Lincoln Center for the subway, we got separated in the throng, and I arrived on the platform just in time to see the subway doors close with my friend inside. We stared at each other for a moment in mute shock, then I watched her move away from me, slowly at first, then faster and farther, until no one would have been able to tell we’d started out together.

How do you manage to nurture, quell, or otherwise live with your envy and schadenfreude when someone you know catapults to literary stardom?

Guest Blogger #2 – Mary S. Beach “I’m just the oily slick on a windup world with a nervous tic.”


I was on a flight from Amsterdam to Newark the other day when I noticed that every other person was reading a Kindle. Then it hit me. I am almost fifty years old and I might never have a book published. By that I mean a real book that I can hold next to my heart and then put away on a shelf. Even better, on my mother’s shelf. Something I can finish. Something I can dedicate. I have written all my life, but nothing has ever been really truly finished. I enjoy my status as a late bloomer, but now I see I may be too late for a real book.
I feel bookless. Like I felt childless at 30.
I might have an electronic book and that would be cool, and sure, I know the important thing is to join the party, the great cosmic conversation that started at the beginning of time and will continue to the very end. But I can’t help feeling like 1s and 0s did not speak the words of Levin and Benjy and Daisy and Raskalnikov. They simply can’t carry that weight.
What is that weight? Does the sharp end of our pencil protect us from the void? Is it the tons of printing press searing words into the paper – forever? Is it the knowledge that once you sign off on your manuscript there is no turning back? Is it the force of gravity itself?

Guest Blog #1 – Vivian Swift

Hello everybody, this is world famous author Vivian Swift filling in for Betsy today. I know, I know — I look familiar: Haven’t we met? I get that all the time. ALL THE TIME. Just last week, at Betsy’s book event at She Writes in Manhattan, I introduced myself to three or four complete strangers and two of them looked at me funny and asked, “Haven’t we met before?” I hate that. Like I said, I get asked that all the time; I just have one of those all-American cover girl faces. And an identical twin sister, but that never figures into the scenario except for that one time in that airport bar in Rome.

When somebody asks, “Haven’t we met?” what they are really saying is “You’re too ordinary for me to remember but I, on the other hand, am unforgettable, so now you have to do all the work and figure out why I think I know you. And make it snappy.”

It’s not that I’m easily offended. (Which I am, but that never figures into the scenario, unless we really have met before, and then I will get all Real Housewives of Atlanta on your ass.)

The reason this question bugs me is because even though I was cautioned by Betsy in the “Publication” chapter of The Forest For The Trees about what getting published will and will not do for your self-esteem, I still think that getting a book published is utterly transforming. Getting published gives you a sheen, a glow, an aura of specialness not unlike a halo — and it annoys me when people don’t see that. For chrissake, I am a published author. I’M IMPORTANT.

But lately I’ve been thinking. Oh sure, once you get published you do rise high above your formerly drab self, it’s true. But then you discover that you’ve been promoted into a whole new world of anonymity — after all, tens of thousands of books are published every year. I’ve read that the number is anywhere from 50 to 80 thousand books in America alone. With all those books that readers have to choose from, then, to those inundated readers you look just like every other author out there. Even if you’re in the ten percent of authors who are really, really cute, that’s still a lot of authors in the beauty pageant.

My job as an author (which is quite different from my job as a writer) is to stand out from the crowd. I remember when Laura Hillenbrand’s book Seabiscuit came out; she got a lot of press for having written a good book, of course — but she got just as much attention about her having written it while suffering from chronic fatigue syndrome. All over the land, talk show hosts and glossy magazine editors got the hots for her because –hallelujah! – they could interview an author who had a completely different story to tell about being a [boring, stay-at-home, intellectual, whiny word-processing] writer! Steig Larson: he went one better than disease — he got dead. Stephanie Myers: Mormon. J. K. Rowling: former welfare mom.

The only thing keeping me off the New York Times best seller list is that I forgot to tell my publisher (when they asked me for my bio) the one, single-most, publicity-sexy thing about me that will make TV, radio, and print editors take notice. And, by extension, make readers by the millions remember me. None of this “Have we met?” shit ever again.

But I’m working on my second book for publication, and this time I’ll be sure to mention that I am Angelina Jolie’s prettier half sister (tres relevant: my book is about France).

What is the sexiest thing about you, as a writer? Whether it’s true or not?

Them a murder me so I gotta murder them first

MY FOURTH QUARTER HATE LIST – 2010

1) The term “frenemy.”

2) New lingo like “webinar” and “twittinar.”

3)  Giving Ben Affleck credit.

4) Windows 7

5) That James Franco is here at Yale and I haven’t seen him, though he has been spotted at Starbucks a zillion times. How much of that swill can I drink?

6) That not including Franzen on the NBA list is making a “statement.”

 

I Break For Amish

 

7) Ben Mezrich’s “Author’s Note” in The Accidental Billionaire. Specifically, “I do employ the technique of recreated dialogue.” Technique? Funny, I thought that was called fiction. He also dedicates his book “To Tonya, this Geek’s Dream Girl.” Aw.

8 ) Here’s what I really hate. These two Hasiddic boys of maybe 16 approach me as I’m going to the Jewish Center where I work out. “Are you Jewish?” they ask me. “Excuse me?” “Are you Jewish?” they ask again. “No, I say, are you?”   They seem stumped. After all they are wearing long black coats, and black hats, and have strings coming out of their clothes. “Are we Jewish?” “Yeah, I say, I thought you were Amish.” Now their eyes go crazy wide. “We’re Jewish! ” they exclaim. I step closer:  “Why don’t you trade  those clothes for some Abercrombie and Fitch and date girls and eat burgers, you know, have fun.” And with that I went inside the JCC and read two People Magazines while I did an interval routine on the epileptic machine. In other words, leave me the fuck alone.

9) Today’s session:  Therapist – 3, Lerner – 0.

10) The new fall line-up. Especially the one about fat, happy people. Ha ha ha.

p.s. if you’re still reading, thanks for all the lovely notes about the NBA nomination for Just Kids. Starting Sunday night, you will be treated to five great Guest Posts, which I think you will enjoy. Thanks to everyone who sent in a post — there were nearly 50 entries.

Baby Was a Black Sheep, Baby Was a Whore

Thirteen years ago, when I was five months pregnant, I had the chance to meet one of my heroes. I can still remember the dress I wore and how I nervously awaited her arrival at an Indian Restaurant high above Central Park South. I chose it for the name, Nirvana. When I met Patti Smith that day, she seemed delighted by my pregnancy and asked about the due date. That’s Darwin’s birthday, she said. I would later learn that Patti knew the birthdays of anyone of significance. My daughter is 13 now, and just starting to play guitar. The book we spoke of that day, a book about you and Robert in your youth, living for art and each other, became something more beautiful than I could have ever hoped for or imagined. And today, it was nominated for a National Book Award. Congratulations, Patti. Just Kids! Just Kids!

I Met Her In a Club Down in Old Soho Where You Drink Champagne and it Tastes Just Like Cherry Soda

 

Those sea horses are creeping me out!

 

I just got invited to speak on a panel about blog burn-out. I declined. I wouldn’t know anything about that. What’s blogger burn-out — when you’re too tired to write about yourself and have lots of people respond who don’t know you and who you are not fucking?  When would I ever get tired of that? Does she mean too exhausted to be self-indulgent? As if! Being tired of blogging would be like being tired of London, or Madmen, or eating. It doesn’t happen, not on my watch. If someone wants to get me to talk about burn-out, they will have to come up with something else like pretending to like people or being positive.

What about you?

They Walked Alone By The Old Canal

Happier times

Do you live inside a shoebox? Are you a scrap of paper tucked inside my notebook? Do you care how the pages feel quilted from pressing down so hard? Or the tape, now yellow, where you pasted in photo booth pictures?  Didn’t you think that someday a biographer, or a graduate student, would stumble upon the two dozen boxes, the twenty-seven notebooks, find the scraps like crumbs leading to your oven. How silly you would sound! How hard it all was! And for what? There are two kinds of people, someone once said, only can’t remember: lefties and righties, innies and outties, assholes and bigger assholes? You can not recall another Fall when the acorns underfoot were so hard to crack.

You Talk Too Much You Never Shut Up

Fuck me, fuck me, fuck me, fuck me. I didn’t touch the screenplay all weekend. I worked instead on what I call “work work.”  Read and edited all weekend. Saw one movie and took two long walks in what was arguably the “perfect fall weekend.” But otherwise, I read. In the hammock, on the patio, on the couch, in my bed. Everywhere I go a trail of manuscript pages and eraser shavings, coffee mugs and Diet Coke cans. I didn’t even read the freakin’ NYT and the cover of the book review is a review of the new Philip Roth by Leah Hager Cohen, whose first two books I edited when I was an editor. I’m saving that for my jammies. What is the point? The point is I preach no excuses and I am full of them. What I should preach is just keep your mouth shut, Lerner, no one wants to hear your excuses.

I would, however, like to hear yours. Especially if they are truly pathetic.

Everybody Knows This is Nowhere

 

My Screenplay

 

I haven’t looked at my screenplay in months. I haven’t exactly been playing mahjong either. The Hose and I wrote our new pilot, I’ve sold a half dozen books, and I’ve gained five pounds. Time consuming! I determined that I would take it out just as soon as we finished the pilot, and that is this weekend. I’m actually afraid to look at it. I actually feel sick thinking about taking it out. I can’t picture anything except Topher Grace pushing himself away from a desk in an Aeron chair. And Marisa Tomei in a wrap-around dress.

I’ve always said that a work in progress is like a patient on an operating table. If you leave it for too long, it flatlines. You have to work on it every day to keep a pulse going. What does it mean to leave your patient on the table? Why does it feel so sickening to get back into it? Why do I sometimes feel I have to “make myself write?”  I fuckin’ hate that. What about you? Do you write every day? How hard is it to get back into once you stop?

Steada Kisses, We Get Kicked

Often when I turn down a project, the writer  will ask me to recommend other agents. Obviously, I would like to help him or her but it’s sticky. In the first place, I often don’t know who to recommend, or I don’t feel comfortable making a referral which implies my belief in the project. But there’s something else: agents do not look kindly on agent referrals — at least in my experience. If a writer approaches me and says Slinky Suburban at ICM thought you might like this, my first thought is: why didn’t Slinky take it on herself? I wonder how other agents feel about this. Are you happy to get a referral, no matter from where? If I turn something down and have a  very strong hunch that another agent will like it because of some inside knowledge, I will refer that agent to the writer — and once in a while make an introduction.

Otherwise, my advice is to go to your library: PublishersMarketplace.com has a database of all deals that have been done over that past five or more years. You can search it by category and agent, and you can quickly come up with a list of appropriate agents to send your work to. Until now, writers had to comb the acknowledgments pages of favorite books, or  hope to meet an agent or two at a conference. Now, you have this remarkable database, you have Publisher’s Weekly on-line, you have agency websites that show you client lists and submission guidelines. I’m not saying it’s easy to get an agent, but it should be easier now than ever before to put a list together of agents to query.

What’s your experience?