525 Comments as of close of day Friday. It was like a freakin’ avalanche. This must be how Bransford feels all the time. I wasn’t sure anyone would even leave a title. So thanks to everyone who participated. To choose “the best,” it was impossible to do anything but sift through the titles as if through a pile of query letters. And I’ve selected those with exactly the same criteria as I do the letters that cross my desk: does the title (and some combination of elements in the letter) make me want to read more?
In Fifth Place: The short stories “The Camera Has Its Reason” and “101 Ways of Hating Claire.” I just like them, the first is kind of heady but also funny, the second, well you know I’m a hater. They’re quirky without being too “quirky.”
In fourth place: The Wrong Daughter (Yes, lots of titles with “daughter” in them these days, but I’ve always felt like the wrong one myself. It’s strong, immediately signals the conflict, and perfect for the women’s fiction market.
In third place: Zebra Crossing (I just like the way it sounds and the visual it immediately creates in my mind.)
In second place: Gardening In Belvoir. I don’t get how it’s a paranormal suspense. It sounds British. But it’s strange and intriguing to me.
In first place: The Pigeon Drop. I love titles that sound good even when I don’t know what they mean, but when I discover the meaning, and in this case it’s the name of a common scam, I love it all the more. I also love stories about con artists, grifters, etc. It sounds original to me, but it also sounds like a bestseller to me, like Michael Connelly could have written it.
Okay, that’s my completely subjective take. Will the author of the Pigeon Drop please send his or her address if you want to redeem your prize of an AUTOGRAPHED copy of the New and Revised FOrest for the Trees. askbetsylerner@gmail.com
Thanks again to everyone who participated. Please feel free to agree, disagree, weigh in. It was thrilling to see such a huge and thoughtful response (August, you too, you know it I love it when crap all over my posts.)
Filed under: Writing | 20 Comments »