• Forest for the Trees
  • THE FOREST FOR THE TREES is about writing, publishing and what makes writers tick. This blog is dedicated to the self loathing that afflicts most writers. A community of like-minded malcontents gather here. I post less frequently now, but hopefully with as much vitriol. Please join in! Gluttons for punishment can scroll through the archives.

    If I’ve learned one thing about writers, it’s this: we really are all alone. Thanks for reading. Love, Betsy

I Love You For Who You Are

Dear Ms. Lerner:

Are there different ‘types’ of client? The midlist author with no idea his career is in irretrievable decline (although you’re fully aware)? The literary author trying to deny the fact that she only had one book in her? The Shotgunner, who sends you a different idea every month? The Hibernator, who you don’t hear a whisper from for years, until a new manuscript arrives at your desk? I’ve always wondered if agents have a ‘Field Guide to Clients.’

Also, what percentage of clients sell a couple of books then never write anything else? What percentage keep writing, but stop selling? For how long?

Sincerely, W

Dear W:  Clients, like agents, come in all shapes and sizes. Insecure, egotistical, driven, lazy, perfectionist, intrepid, resourceful, blaming, determined, fragile, headstrong, complaining, stoic,  you name it. I think I even wrote a book about it. More interesting is to watch how any given writer responds to going through the process of sending  out his work, looking for an agent, getting a publisher, getting his edits all the way through to post-publication. Every aspect about the writing process is character-defining.  For instance, when one writer gets rejected he takes his marbles and runs home. Another swears he will never quit as a result of getting turned down – he doesn’t care by how many. One writer gets a great review, believes his own press and never writes another true word. Another writer gets a great review and develops a case of stage fright, never writing another word. One writer gets slammed by reviews and becomes a pit bull, another grows timid and eventually silent. Your books slips beneath the waves: do you?  A Field Guide to Getting Your Ass Kicked is more like it. A Field Guide to self-loathing and doubt, a guide to self-flagellation and self-aggrandizement and hemorrhoidal hell. A field guide to every insecure thought and jealous rage. A field guide to my brilliance, to my ass, to misanthropy, my loneliness, my love. What species are you?

The Way I Feel When I’m In Your Hands

My office is starting to look like a maternity ward at the full moon; it feels like all my clients are delivering their pages at the same moment whether it’s a final manuscript, a draft, a chapter, a treatment, a partial. If I know one thing about writers it’s that they hate waiting to hear what people think. The minute they hit send, the bomb starts to tick. Lots of writers go right to the dark place, imagine the worst. Though some are confident, and when they hand you the pages they will tell you so. It makes me think of a small child proudly handing you a page from a coloring book, the crayon insanely outside the lines. Some go into free fall and pick at their own flesh. Some start shooting off revisions: Wait! Read this draft! or If you haven’t read yet! It’s the worst, like waiting for a guy to call after you’ve fucked him.

How do you handle it, the waiting? The horror.

When I Found Out Yesterday

Today, a new media person came to our office and told us about her company and what it can do for authors. It’s a very interesting model and if you have the right kind of book/platform, it looks like you can really make some bank. I’m intrigued, but it also makes me feel very Rip Van Winkly.

Later in the day, a rejection letter came in that was so kind and smart that I nearly wept. No publishing jargon about cups of tea or falling between stools. Just a straight up smart read from an editor who is old school and by that I mean she reads her own manuscripts and writes her own letters and has strong opinions which she expresses politely.

Then I wrote a very good letter to a very famous author asking for a very big favor. Getting blurbs is the equivalent of big game hunting for sedentary publishing types like myself with big beautiful asses. Please god of the blurbs, rain on me.

Then I helped my partner choose editors for a submission he is making. This is like culling a list together for a dinner party. Then I got an email from a prospective client who says another agent is interested in her. I hadn’t even received the material. Am I being played? I don’t care — it sounds great. I’ll take a peek on the train tonight. The thing about reading under these circumstances is that you naturally feel competitive and read it differently as a result. Note to self: cool jets. It was a perfect query letter, the project comes with a killer title; has this little darling been reading my blog??

And the day didn’t end there, chit chat in the elevator with a publisher, lunch with a southern author and her marvelous drawl and bright blue eyes, doing the memo on two contracts (boring), gossiping about Bill Clegg (not boring), etc. etc.

Tell me about your writing day if you like. What did you get done? Any good gossip?

That’s Where You’ll Find Me

Do you ever regret anything you’ve written, wish you hadn’t published it, or even just shared it with another person? Now that my daughter is a teen, I sometimes gulp hard to think of what she will think of me if she reads my memoir. I was quite cavalier when I wrote it. My motto: secrets did the most damage. It was the stuff under the carpet that kills. Now, the carpet’s looking mighty fine.

Please tell me about literary regrets. The more self-flagellating and recriminating the better.

Sun Down, Yellow Moon

I’ve been trying to write about something that happened two weeks ago. I was in therapy and I did something I’ve never done before: I told my shrink what my screenplay was “about.” Actually, I told her the plot, more specifically about the two main characters and how I couldn’t write what I had planned about them. Just as I said it, I knew for the first time what the story was really about, who these characters were. I had led myself right back into the central drama of our family (once again) even as I believed I was writing about entirely different creatures.

I raced home and wrote the ending. And another new experience: it wrote itself. All the plot lines like a row of dominoes falling in a long line of deeply pleasurable inevitability capped off with the pure satisfaction of the final tile hitting the table. Done. Only then, an angel descended and gave me a final image so strange I could have never thought of it.

Are you in therapy? Does it help you? Your work? Do you think it’s bad for your work? Did you ever sleep with your therapist. Do you give your therapist your writing/books? Have you ever solved a specific writing problem in therapy?

You’re Leaving There Too Soon

You talkin' to me?

Two summers ago, Irwin Winkler became interested in my screenplay, Sugar Mountain. Over a six week period, he gave me notes and expected me to turn them around in a week, which I dutifully did, gleefully did. I didn’t agree with all the notes, and when I bravely objected once or twice he disarmingly replied, “Give it a try.” It was impossible to refute. I was old enough to appreciate what I came to feel was a master class in screenwriting. Irwin, in essence, taught me action.

At the end of the six weeks, his assistant called and asked if I could meet Irwin, now back from Capri, at this apartment in the Pierre. Okay. We spent one hour together going over the script. As he thumbed through it, he suggested a few more tweaks. One or twice he said something like, nice job.  I would send in the cleaned up draft and he would send it to the actor for whom he had it in mind. Someone, by the way, who I always felt was wrong for the part, but if Irwin wanted Charlie the Tuna to play my lead male, that would have been hunky dory with moi.

When I left the apartment that night, Irwin shook my hand. “One question,” he said, “Sugar Mountain, what does it mean?”

Obviously it didn’t go anywhere. I sent it to a bunch of other producers. One nibble, enough to start crafting my academy award speech once again. Then, silence. This post is dedicated to close calls. Do they kill you or make you stronger?

I’m Gonna Live Forever

Can you guess who the writer is?

While we are on the subject of the undead, let’s talk about day jobs. I want to know where you guys work and if your colleagues know that there is an undead among them. I also want to know if you think writing in the night, and later night, the dead of night and wee hours is good for your writing. And if being an undead helps your writing or sucks all the life blood out of you.

I would like to complain about how being in publishing is probably the worst thing for my writing life, but that’s not true. For fuck’s sake, I eat, live and breath the shit. Does taking 15% make me a vampire?

But what’s it like working among civilians, people who don’t understand or care that you are not really alive unless you are bathed in the light of the computer screen. After all, what’s a book but a bid for immortality? Suck it.

Little Old Lady Got Mutilated Late Last Night

Literary Novelist Turns to Vampires and Finds Pot of Gold

Justin Cronin at an annual book industry convention in New York last week.
Chad Batka for The New York Times — DOESN’T THIS LOOK LIKE A LOT OF FUN??

By JULIE BOSMAN
Published: June 1, 2010

Justin Cronin is the author of an epic, multimillion-dollar, 766-page novel that stars bloodthirsty creatures that run in packs and savagely kill people at night. And he’s planning to turn it into a trilogy.

Dearest darling readers of this blog: Take a moment to read the NYT article about Justin Cronin if you haven’t already. And then tell me, WTF, why isn’t that US? Why aren’t we buying our daughter a pony. Why didn’t we initiate a game “Let’s Plan a Novel Together?” (I actually play this with my daughter all the time but we’ve never gotten past the first few sentences.) Why didn’t we sell film rights to Scott Free Productions with John Logan writing? Why are we not Justin Cronin. And try as I might to hate him and his good fortune, he seems great. Kids, for the umpteenth time: a vampire novel! Please!

What I really want to know, though, is how do these articles make you feel? Hopeful? Inspired? August?

Didn’t I Give You Nearly Everything That a Woman Possibly Can?

Exhausted. Fell asleep on the train. All my manuscripts slipped off my lap and on to the floor. The woman next to me didn’t flinch or shift her legs as I frantically gathered my pages (today’s haul: four new chapters by a client, 50 pages of a project my business partner wants a second opinion on, four prospective proposals, and two contracts). The bitch who won’t move is immersed in a library copy of Debbie Macomber’s novel, A Good Yarn. (The head line on Debbie’s website is, “Wherever you are, Debbie takes you home.”) Debbie, can you take me home?

The lady who doesn’t move wears pale salmon huarache style loafers. I notice them because I am still on the floor picking up pages. It’s times like these when you think about an iPad. Only knowing me, the iPad would probably slip off my lap and break. And as a result some other dumb ass agent will read the proposal first and procure a seven figure advance while I’m still playing with myself. Or maybe, everything will come to nothing, except my book bag which will be on display at the Smithsonian as a relic of when people used to read books.

And this permanent knot in my shoulder from carrying my book bag, it too will be under glass at the museum. And the twitch in my right eye that moves like filigree, that’s a popular exhibit. In fact, all of my twitches are on display. And that is a case of my cuticles. And my middle finger, behind glass, spot lit. And the small of my back. And my back. And my throat.

Is this a post or a cry for help?

Faces Come Out of the Rain

On the other hand

Hello Betsy,

Thank you for making yourself available for questions. I’ve read conflicting opinions about the following:

Is it a good idea to include a photograph in the bio portion of the book proposal?

Thank you,

Name Withheld

Dear Name Withheld:

No, it is not. I’ve seen quite a few. Everything from 8 x 10 glossy head shots to a guy standing in a motor boat holding a big fish. I’ve seen bikini clad women, candid photos of friends at Hooters, college year book photos, at a lectern giving a speech, you name it. Unless you are a body builder writing about body building, please keep your pecs to yourself. For some reason author photos look amateurish and grasping when they arrive with proposals and manuscripts. How then can it be explained why we love having them inside book jackets?

Another publishing conundrum.

Thanks for writing. Betsy