• Forest for the Trees
  • THE FOREST FOR THE TREES is about writing, publishing and what makes writers tick. This blog is dedicated to the self loathing that afflicts most writers. A community of like-minded malcontents gather here. I post less frequently now, but hopefully with as much vitriol. Please join in! Gluttons for punishment can scroll through the archives.

    If I’ve learned one thing about writers, it’s this: we really are all alone. Thanks for reading. Love, Betsy

I Am AN ISland

It’s that time again: HATE LIST.

1) People asking me what I think about Amazon publishing books.

2) People asking me if I’ve read Fifty Shades of Gray.

3) Jennifer Anniston’s new guy.

4) My insane jealousy of Aaron Sorkin.

5) Flats that make  your feet looked webbed.

6) The Dukan Diet and everyone telling me about it.

7) That Tosh is already represented.

8) That I am an adolescent boy trapped in the body of a middle-aged woman.

9) Scramble with Friends and my nemesis City of Angels

10)  Every blogger who becomes a huge bestseller who is not me.

DId I miss anything?

As I Was Walking That Ribbon of Highway

In the current issue of Poets & Writers, there is a section called “Critical Links,” and it charts how the author found the agent found the editor. Just as I always like to know how couples first met, I love to know how writers hook up with their agents, and how their agents in turn get them placed with publishers. It’s a form of matchmaking, and since I’m probably more interested in relationships than anything else I could read about these hook ups all night. For me, most of my clients come from referrals, from other writers, from editors. Some were friends from graduate school. Some queried me and I just liked the sound of their letter or project. And some I stalked.

What are your critical links?

Don’t Ever Look Back, Don’t Ever Look Back

So I’m competing for a new client. He has just published an article in the NYT and a number of agents and editors have contacted him — me among them. I write a friendly email introducing myself and why I’ve responded to his article. I acknowledge that his in-box is probably flooded but I’d love to throw my hat in the ring if he’s interested in writing a book. I receive a cordial email back. Yes, there’s lots of interest. Yes, he’d love to meet. We set a date to have coffee. The date goes well. We talk for over an hour. Small talk (we’re both Yankee fans, we both went to Harvard, we both love Pinkberry’s salted caramel flavor) followed by nuts and bolts. The only point of contention between us is how much of a proposal he needs to write  to sell the book. I’m old-fashioned in this regard and feel that a prospective author improves his chances for the best advance possible if he goes the extra mile with the proposal. Having worked at four publishing houses, I remember well how the publishers disdained the agents who turned in shabby or half-baked proposals. Though there were always exceptions when less was more. There is certainly no one right way to sell a book. I can tell the writer wants to write a brief proposal. I don’t know how hard to push for a more fleshed out proposal; doing so might compromise the chance to sign him.

Do I stick to my guns or tell him what he wants to hear?

With Trunks of Memories Still To COme

You are the captain of your own ship. My grandmother used to say that when I was young and I would actually see myself as a child in grown up clothes, Naval dress, standing in the prow of a ship, a large hat swimming on my head, long pant legs cascading over my feet. A sort of Wes Anderson tableau. As I got older, I saw myself as more of a wayfarer in the middle of the ocean, more daring, more beautiful, thinner, and with lustrous brown hair clipped back in a tortoise shell barrette. Now, there is no image, just this clarion call, this fierce reminder in one’s ability to chart the course of her life. Why do I bring it up tonight? Perhaps to remind myself to hang in, that not knowing how to revise or what the next step is doesn’t render me finished, that all is not lost when you put another script in a casket and dig a six foot hole and when the first shovel of dirt is your own. Or when your new “idea” is only that or less than that because the execution evades you, or when you start to doubt the whole endeavor, when you fondly think back to high school and college when you were the queen of bagging groceries (winner of the cleanest station of the week 14 weeks in a row) or serving quiche at a pretentious cafe, or decorating the whale room in the Natural History Museum with a thousand neon green and blue streamers. An underwater diorama. Kissing a boy you had a crush on in that stream of crepe anemone. Remember this: Don’t give up the ship.

Are you the captain?

Before That Moment You Touch My Lips THat Perfect Feeling WHen TIme Just Slips

This morning I wrote an essay inspired by the deaths of Whitney Houston  and Mary Kennedy. I had been thinking about them, but hadn’t plan to write anything and certainly not this morning when I had two editorial letters to write and a half dozen manuscripts to read. When I looked up, I had six pages and two hours had gone by. Blip. The question is: is the piece any good? WHen something comes out in a rush of energy, it’s easy to get carried away, think it’s better than it is.  I guess the real test would be to send it out. Are rejections and acceptances the only gauge? What about personal satisfaction. What about those two hours spent so happily in Neverland. Does that count?

Does that happen to you? Time disappears when you’re writing? Does it get any better?

Work It On Out

Tonight I went to hear some music that is part of an annual series called “Arts & Ideas.” It’s  festival that brings in a palette of international performers,  musicians, artists, etc. It’s really quite impressive and I feel like a petulant child to say that it makes my skin crawl. I’m not sure if it’s the arts or the ideas, or the way it’s all served up on a bed of bright lettuce, or maybe it’s just the word “festival” that makes me want to wear velvet slippers with tiny jingle bells. I hated the concert tonight so much that I leaned over and whispered to my husband that I wanted to go He mouthed back, “what?” I leaned in to say it again when the man in back of us tapped my shoulder and said, “would you stop talking.” THere is some dispute as to whether he said “stop talking” or “PLEASE stop talking.” Whatever. I wanted to die and then I wanted to kill him. I spent the balance of the performance fantasizing about how I was going to turn around and say: why don’t you shut the fuck up. Or, what the fuck is it to you? Or, you really wanna fuck with me mother fucker. But instead I just slumped down and tried to drown out the concert, and stop thinking about how badly I wanted fro-yo.

How do you handle people who talk in theaters, or are you one?

My Baby Don’t Mess Around

Just in from a late night of boozin’ and brawlin’ at a launch party for The Orphanmaster. I love nothing more than knocking back a few diet Cokes and confronting the  author’s sib when he confessed he hadn’t read her book yet. Yeah, let’s take it outside. Was that me who said you have to be supportive of your siblings? Me, from the Cain and Abel Driving School. And there are all the people from your life like some insane Facebook page come to life, who ring around the rosy and cheer because it isn’t every day or everyone who can bring a book into the world. A book.  A book. A book. Jean looked so beautiful up on the podium, taking us through a series of slides  depicting New Amsterdam and Dutch habits and fashions (muffs!) of the time. It was an ingenious way of introducing the world of her novel. I could have watched a hundred more slides because she so deftly explained what was special about each one and it was infectious. I looked around at the people and everyone had their best fifth grade face on.

Someone asked how I came to represent Orphanmaster. Well, I’ll tell you. I met Jean at Columbia. She was a year ahead of me and her poetry was amazing. She was amazing, not like all the other beret wearing monsters. She was bright, alive, and had no patience for  nonsense. I admired her and was intimidated by her. She shined her light on me and we became friends. And then I became her editor for her non-fiction books, and then her agent. Can you believe it. Jean! We’ve been married for 27 years. Congrats, old friend.

Do your sibs read your work?

I’m Tired I’m So Tired

I’m in a good mood. I admit it. Sorry, August. But since I’ve been back, there’s been a lot of good news. So much so, that a) I’m sure I’ll be hit by a car and b) leads me to believe that going away for ten days might be the ticket instead of sitting at my desk and gnawing at my limbs and digits. The truth is I’ve learned over the years how to compartmentalize the agony associated with waiting to hear if an offer will be tendered, if a book gets reviewed in the NYT, if there will be a movie deal, if there will be a Turkish deal, if the jacket will be beautiful, if the title will be perfect, if the writer  produces a book better than he or she thought possible, and beyond what anyone expected. I first learned how to wait as a teenager waiting for guys to call. Here’s what I could accomplish while waiting: organize my drawers, whiten my teeth, decoupage a box I bought at a tag sale, tweeze my eyebrows beyond recognition, re-read Me, Natalie, and eat a pound of pasta. As an agent, I handle the waiting by getting busy with administrative duties and sometimes slipping into a movie.

How do you handle waiting?

I’ll Follow You Until You Love Me


I can’t believe I’ve been blogging this long and have never shared this particular annoyance. But driving today, I heard an author on NPR commit the sin like seven times. I never caught his name, but he peppered his interview with, “as I say in my book,” “as I write in my book,” “well, according to my new book.” You get the idea. Even worse than hearing this on the radio is being trapped by this sort of blowhard at a cocktail party or to your left at a dinner party. I know authors are told to refer to their books when being interviewed to impress upon the audience that they are selling a book. Still, it feels so forced to me:

Q: What kind of vegetables do they grow in Madagascar?

A: As I say in my book, the most popular vegetable in Madagascar is the tuber.

Q: Do writers like to take it up the arse?

A: Well, according to the studies I cite in my book, writers prefer whatever.

My father  once asked me how I got to be so judgmental when I criticized a friend for always putting a smiley face at the end of her name. I mean, aren’t some things just unforgivable?

Cause If You Miss It I Feel Sorry, Sorry For You

June brings the arrival of two new books from my agenting corner of the sky.

The Orphanmaster by Jean Zimmerman is about as fully furnished an historical novel as you are likely to read. The one line pitch: a serial killer in Colonial America. Here’s  a review fromUSA Today. You will feel absolutely transported to the Dutch Colony of Manhattan, you will be amazed at how deftly Jean weaves in the history and artifacts of the day into  a seamless story you can’t put down. In it you will find a dissolute killer, a strong young woman trader, a British spy, a seven foot slave, a jilted suitor, and a morally corrupt Orphanmaster among others! It’s also really scary. “The Orphanmaster is a sweeping novel of great and precise imaginative intelligence; it’s also the most entertaining and believable historical novel I’ve read in years. Jean Zimmerman is a debut novelist who already writes like an old master. Read any page of The Orphanmaster and you’ll become an instant fan.” – Darin Strauss, author of Half a Life and Chang and Eng

Please get your adult diapers handy for David Yoo’s The Choke Artist: Confessions of a Chronic Underachiever. The one line on this:  An hilarious collection of essays about cultural stereotypes and Yoo’s resolute  insistence on defying all of them. No violin, no SATs off the charts, no straight A’s and pocket protectors. More, it’s about internalized racism and assimilation. But it never gets preachy or full of itself. Yoo’s self-deprecating humor and genius for comic timing keep you turning pages. “Reading THE CHOKE ARTIST is like watching someone get kicked in the nuts-in a good way. Yoo makes us laugh and wince and relive the horrific, hilarious agony of being young.”-Annie Choi, author of Happy Birthday or Whatever And from the Tiger Mom herself, Amy Chua: “I loved this book and couldn’t put it down! It’s raw, startling, laugh-out-loud funny.”

Guys, were you to judge a book by its cover, what would you say?

P.S. If  you have a chance to read either or both! books,  please spread the word, leave bitchin’ ass comments on Amazon, etc. Thanks so much. It’s actually good to be back and thanks for dropping by while I was mini-golfing and keeping the thread going. And  yes, I prevailed. Love, Betsy